Hi, it’s Alex from Progi. It’s Capacity Month, and today I want to talk about insured clients who decide not to claim.

The sluggish economy of the past few years is prompting drivers to make choices. When faced with a repair, some file a claim with their insurer, others pay out of pocket, while some decide the dent can wait.

Earlier this month, we discussed the decline in the number of repairs being handled by insurers. Several factors may be contributing to this drop. Some clients hesitate to claim after an accident: either they can’t afford the deductible, or they don’t want to risk seeing their annual premium go up. For a minor repair, they may also simply decide a claim isn’t worth the trouble.

This phenomenon is hard to quantify. Accidents that go unreported don’t come with a report explaining why. And one fewer claim doesn’t necessarily mean one fewer repair: some customers pay for the work out of pocket.

This is the client base we’re focusing on here. So, the million-dollar question: are you interested in these clients, too?

According to Canadian data from AutoHouse Technologies published in Collision Repair, the average invoice for a customer-pay job was about $1,700 in September 2026, compared with about $5,300 for an insurer-paid job. That’s roughly one third the amount. But that doesn’t necessarily mean three times less attractive: it all depends on the work involved, the time required, and the margin you’re left with.

If your shop’s workload has dropped, it may be worth considering these jobs. But there are a few things to keep in mind.

Clients may be willing to pay out of pocket, even for fairly substantial work. However, they want to know whether the repair is worth what they’re about to spend. And that amount can represent a significant portion of their budget. So they’ll be paying close attention to the price, but also to the result.

How many $1,700 jobs do you think there are in your area? Do these jobs interest you?

First tip: make sure you and the client clearly agree on the work and expectations, ideally in writing. What will be repaired? What won’t be? What result can the client expect? And how will you proceed if disassembly reveals additional damage?

You can agree to leave an unrelated scratch for another time. A clear estimate sets these limits and helps prevent easily avoidable conflicts.

Optimizing your sales mix to make better use of your shop’s capacity is important. However, it’s also important to maintain the level of service you provide to your key business partners while keeping your company’s best interests in mind. The goal is to fit the right jobs in at the right time and earn a healthy margin on them.

Your equipment, your facilities, and your team represent significant investments. Making better use of their capacity means getting more out of them without necessarily expanding the shop.

If you’d like help planning your capacity more effectively and determining where these jobs could fit in, contact us to learn about ProgiPlanning.

_

Written by: Alexandre Rocheleau
Reviewed and translated by: Krystel Henley-Rocheleau